The INS News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Regional
    • Srinagar
    • Jammu
    • National
    • World
  • Business & Economy
  • Multimedia
    • Photo Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Health
  • Jobs & Careers
  • Press Releases
  • Blog
  • Home
  • News
    • Regional
    • Srinagar
    • Jammu
    • National
    • World
  • Business & Economy
  • Multimedia
    • Photo Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Health
  • Jobs & Careers
  • Press Releases
  • Blog
No Result
View All Result
The INS News
No Result
View All Result
Home News Regional

Journalists are free to investigate but can’t pronounce anyone guilty, rules Delhi HC

INS Correspondent by INS Correspondent
December 3, 2017
A A
Accused can’t be punished on moral conviction or suspicion: HC 
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterWhatsappTelegramEmail

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Saturday refused to grant an injunction in the plea by Senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor against allegedly defamatory reporting on Sunanda Pushkar’s death by Republic TV and its star anchor Arnab Goswami.

RELATED POSTS

5 terrorist aides booked under PSA in Sgr

MeT predicts rain, thunderstorm till tomorrow

Eid-ul-Azha: JKCSF-JKPUF urge timely redressal of public, education, welfare sector issues

The Single Judge Bench of Justice Manmohan held that:

“Irrespective of the style of reporting and the remarks made, this Court is prima facie of the view that reporting in the present matter is a case of legitimate investigative journalism as even three and a half years after the death of Ms. Sunanda Pushkar, wife of a then sitting Union Minister, no charge-sheet has been filed.”

Tharoor had filed a petition against Goswami and his channel seeking compensation and damages from him for making defamatory remarks. He also asked for a prohibitory injunction restraining the defendants from reporting any news related to the death of Sunanda Pushkar till the investigation is complete.

The Court, during earlier hearings, had asked Goswami to tone down the rhetoric and had stated that any person, including an accused, has a right to silence.

Appearing for Tharoor, Senior Counsel and fellow Congress leader Salman Khurshid argued that the defendants had neither regretted nor taken back the allegations made over such a long period of time.

He stated that Tharoor does not seek a blanket gag order, but wants relief restraining the defendants from making any defamatory allegations, insinuations, opinions and casting aspersions in relation to the death of his wife, which is under investigation.

Buy JNews
ADVERTISEMENT

Representing Goswami, Senior Advocate Sandeep Sethi contended that Tharoor had handpicked and selectively quoted the allegedly defamatory remarks without providing context.

He further stated that Tharoor harboured personal animosity against Goswami since 2010, as the latter had probed the alleged misuse of office by Tharoor with regard to the Kochi franchise of the Indian Premier League.

The Court, while refusing to stop the media house from airing stories relating to the mysterious death of Pushkar, observed that the presumption of innocence and a fair trial are at the heart of criminal jurisprudence.

“Journalists are free to investigate but they cannot pronounce anyone guilty and/or pre judge the issue and/or prejudice the trial. The grant of the fairest of the opportunity to the accused to prove his innocence is the object of every fair trial.”

The Court further observed that every individual/accused has a right to silence under the Constitution, and that no person can be compelled to give testimony or answer questions that may lead to incrimination.

“The ‘culture of thrusting a microphone’ in the face of a person needs to be deprecated.”

The Court also took note of Tharoor’s famous tweet wherein he had described Goswami as an ‘unprincipled showman masquerading as a journalist‘. In response to this tweet, Goswami had called Tharoor an ‘unprincipled criminal masquerading as a politician’. On a lighter note, the Court stated,

“TV viewers who want to watch action films should not watch TV debates on current affairs on the ground that it contains more action and violence than any action film.”

Finally, the Court asked the news channel to give Tharoor a written notice asking for his version, before airing any stories pertaining to him. If he refuses or does not reply within a reasonable time, he should not be compelled to speak and the story should be aired with a disclosure that the he has refused to speak to the channel.

Previous Post

Kohli breaks Lara’s record of most Test double tons as skipper

Next Post

Iran inaugurates Chabahar port extension

INS Correspondent

INS Correspondent

Related Posts

3 hardcore OGWs booked under PSA in Kishtwar
Regional

5 terrorist aides booked under PSA in Sgr

June 2, 2025
Weather to remain cloudy till Oct 28
Regional

MeT predicts rain, thunderstorm till tomorrow

June 2, 2025
JKCSF hopes for comprehensive overhaul of J&K’s education system
Regional

Eid-ul-Azha: JKCSF-JKPUF urge timely redressal of public, education, welfare sector issues

June 2, 2025
Veteran NC leader Rahim Rather set to be elected as Speaker
Regional

Speaker to discuss functioning of House Committees tomorrow

June 1, 2025
AEJAK, ASMEA present memorandum of demands to LG Sinha
Regional

AEJAK, ASMEA present memorandum of demands to LG Sinha

May 31, 2025
J&K has immense opportunity in tourism sector: PM Modi
Regional

‘Operation Sindoor’ India’s biggest anti-terror success: PM Modi in Bhopal

May 31, 2025
Next Post
Iran inaugurates Chabahar port extension

Iran inaugurates Chabahar port extension

Hurriyat (M) condemns use of force against students

Mirwaiz expresses concern over ‘rise’ in social evils

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




China launches satellite for Pakistan

July 9, 2018
Sarpanch kills his wife with VDC rifle in Rajouri, arrested: Police

CIK arrests youth trying to join terrorist ranks in Budgam

May 2, 2024

532 new cases take in J&K, covid-19 tally crosses 98000 mark

November 7, 2020

About

Indian News Service (INS) is the first registered online news portal from the state of Jammu & Kashmir. Our creative team consists of like-minded and socially concerned team of media professionals who carry decades of experience in their field of profession at their back. Our core values have pillars in honesty, empathy, credibility, equality and integrity.

More

© 2022 INS News - Designed by GITS.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Regional
    • Srinagar
    • Jammu
    • National
    • World
  • Business & Economy
  • Multimedia
    • Photo Gallery
    • Video Gallery
  • Health
  • Jobs & Careers
  • Press Releases
  • Blog

© 2022 INS News - Designed by GITS.